Back to News
quantum-computing

Is the QFT physically realizable for modest qubits?

Reddit r/QuantumComputing (RSS)
Loading...
1 min read
0 likes
⚡ Quantum Brief
An electrical engineer questions the physical feasibility of quantum Fourier transforms (QFT) for breaking RSA encryption, citing Shor’s algorithm’s reliance on ultra-precise phase gates with π/2^n accuracy. The core issue is implementing phase gates with 4096-bit precision—required for modern RSA—demanding precision exceeding cosmic scales, comparable to the observable universe’s size versus Planck length. The engineer highlights that even modest qubit counts (40+) seem unrealizable for QFT, given current hardware limitations and the exponential precision demands of phase operations. No known physical system can achieve such precision, raising doubts about practical quantum attacks on RSA, despite theoretical polynomial-time solutions via Shor’s algorithm. The post asks whether workarounds exist to bypass these precision barriers, leaving the scalability of quantum factoring in question for near-term devices.
Is the QFT physically realizable for modest qubits?

Summarize this article with:

I’m not an expert in quantum computing. I’m just an electrical engineer who’s interested in quantum computing because of its implications for encryption. Shor’s algorithm can break RSA encryption in polynomial complexity. The algorithm relies on a quantum Fourier transform in n qubits where n is the number of classical bits of the semiprime that you’re trying to factor. From what I’ve read just on Wikipedia, the QFT requires a phase gate with π/2^n phase change. I may be missing something, but I don’t really understand how a practical phase gate with the required precision for modern encryption could ever be implemented. Modern RSA typically uses 4096 bit modulus. What physical system could create a phase change with 4096-bit precision? That’s more than 1000 orders of magnitude. That’s larger than ratio of the size of the observable universe to the Planck length. It’s larger than the ratio of the age of the observable universe to Planck time. Is there a workaround to using such precise phase gates? Even a modest number of qubits (more than 40) doesn’t seem realizable for QFT. submitted by /u/DiscretePoop [link] [comments]

Read Original

Tags

government-funding
quantum-computing
quantum-algorithms
quantum-hardware

Source Information

Source: Reddit r/QuantumComputing (RSS)