A materials scientist’s playground

Scientists and engineers around the world are working to improve quantum bits, or qubits, the minuscule building blocks of the quantum computer. Qubits are incredibly sensitive, making it easy for errors to be introduced, lowering device yield. But a new cluster tool at MIT.nano introduces capabilities that will allow researchers to continue advancements in qubit performance.Passersby outside MIT.nano may have recently noticed a complex looking piece of equipment being installed on the first-floor cleanroom. What looks like a sci-fi movie prop is actually a state-of-the-art, custom-built molecular beam epitaxy (MBE): a physical vapor deposition system that operates under ultra-high vacuum to produce high-quality thin films. With the ability to grow different crystalline materials on a wafer, the tool will support quantum researchers and materials scientists by allowing them to study how film growth affects the properties of the materials used in making qubits.“To realize the full promise of quantum computing, we need to build qubits that are robust, reproducible, and extensible,” says William D. Oliver, the Henry Ellis Warren (1894) Professor of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science and professor of physics at MIT. “To date, most of the improvements to superconducting qubit performance are traceable to circuit design — essentially, designing qubit circuits that are less sensitive to their environmental noise. However, those improvements have largely run their course. Going forward, we need to address the fundamental materials science and fabrication engineering required to reduce the sources of environmental noise. This multi-chamber, cassette-loaded, 200-millimeter wafer MBE system is exactly the right tool at the right time. And there’s no place better to do this research than at MIT.nano.”That is because MIT.nano is preconditioned to receive this type of system with physical space, climate controls, policies and procedures for researchers, and expert staff to manage the lab. Through an equipment support plan, Oliver’s Engineering Quantum Systems (EQuS) group is able to install and run the tool inside MIT.nano, a high-performance, safe, and reliable environment.A controlled environment is essential for the MBE. “Think of this system like an inverted International Space Station (ISS),” explains Patrick Strohbeen, research scientist in the EQuS group. “The ISS is a small chamber of atmosphere surrounded by the vacuum of space. This MBE system is a chamber of space-level vacuum surrounded by atmosphere.” That vacuum of space is kept at a steady negative 90 degrees Celsius, which enables precise growth of thin films on an atomic scale. It is the largest single deposition chamber (1-meter diameter) the manufacturer, DCA, has sold in the United States.The journey of a waferThe system, which in total takes up 600 square feet, is made up of six chambers. First is the load lock, where the wafer is placed into the system and brought down from atmospheric pressure to near the vacuum level of space. Then, the wafer enters the distribution center. This space acts like a central hub, transferring the wafers to other chambers. Next is the deposition, or “growth,” chamber. This is where the system’s primary function takes place — depositing materials, specifically atoms of superconducting metal, onto a substrate, typically silicon. From there, it moves to the oxidation chamber, which facilitates the growth of key ceramic materials for qubits. A fifth storage chamber can hold an additional 10 wafers within the vacuum.A unique aspect of this system is its sixth chamber, designed for X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS). Using this chamber, researchers can shoot a photon in the form of X-rays at the surface and, when it hits the surface, it will excite the electron inside the material so that the electron jumps out and is picked up by a sensor that then tells the researcher about the environment the electron came from. As individual layers of atoms are put down in the growth chamber, scientists can move the wafer to the XPS chamber to measure changes in the material structure of the film and back again, all while keeping it inside the vacuum space.Why is this important? “The quantum community has excellent device physicists and device engineers,” said Strohbeen. “The last piece of the puzzle is: We need to understand the materials platform that we’re using for these devices.” The buried interfaces, so far, have been understudied due to the difficulty in probing them, he explained.For those of us who are not MBE experts, think of the snow that fell in Massachusetts this winter. How can you tell how much ice is on the pavement without removing all of the snow on top of it? And without changing the natural setting where the snow, ice, and pavement meet? With this system, specifically the XPS chamber, scientists can study the interfaces of buried materials without disturbing the physical or chemical environments. “It is a materials scientist’s playground,” jokes Strohbeen — a controlled space where researchers can learn about and explore materials’ interactions within layers of atoms.Why MIT.nano?When Oliver, who is also the director of the MIT Center for Quantum Engineering, secured the MBE Quantum, the next question was where to put it. Enter MIT.nano. Housing 45,000 square feet of cleanroom, this facility exists at MIT to support complex, sensitive equipment with both the infrastructure and the staff needed to maintain it.“MIT.nano’s ultra-stable building utilities and lab environment are exactly what is needed to support a system that demands extreme repeatability and purity,” says Nick Menounos, MIT.nano associate director of infrastructure. “The success of this installation grew from the early collaboration. Professor Oliver engaged the MIT.nano team in the procurement process almost two years in advance. That foresight, combined with the infrastructure momentum we gained from the recent CHIPS Act project, meant that we could prepare the cleanroom perfectly. We compressed the installation process that normally takes several months and had this extraordinary machine running in under three weeks.”“From the very beginning, the MIT.nano staff were helpful, knowledgeable, and willing to go above and beyond to make this happen,” says Oliver. “While the MIT.nano facility is certainly an infrastructural crown jewel at MIT, it’s the MIT.nano staff who make it the national treasure it is today.”Positioning the MBE Quantum in the cleanroom helps the team focus on scalability and device yield. Humidity and particle count, two things carefully measured and maintained at MIT.nano, can affect the output of the device. Minimizing as many variables as possible is key to improving qubit performance. The cleanroom also allows for new device research because an array of fabrication and metrology tools are available without having to leave the clean environment.“We’re really excited to see what we can do with it,” says Strohbeen. “We bought it as a materials science tool, and it will also be a device development tool due to the flexibility of having it in the cleanroom.”The MBE system was purchased through a combination of grants from the Army Research Office (ARO) and from the Laboratory for Physical Sciences (LPS). The ARO grant, a Defense University Research Instrumentation Program grant, is the premier grant from ARO for funding large capital equipment purchases that should prove disruptive in technologically relevant areas. It arrives at an important time on campus, as one of MIT’s strategic initiatives — the MIT Quantum Initiative — aims to apply quantum breakthroughs to the most consequential challenges in science, technology, industry, and national security.